Lone Peak 9 GTX vs Timp 5 GTX ROA: Which Waterproof Altra?
By Running Shoes with FootShape™ Comfort | Altra Running US | Published: 2026-10-31
Category: Comparisons
Compare the men's Lone Peak 9 GTX and women's Timp 5 GTX ROA on waterproofing, grip, cushioning, and fit. Find out which Altra GORE-TEX trail shoe suits your terrain.
Quick answer
Choose the men's Lone Peak 9 GTX if you want a classic, slightly cushioned trail feel with sticky MaxTrac grip for mixed wet terrain. Choose the women's Timp 5 GTX ROA if you prioritize a cushioned, waterproof ride and a fashion-forward trail look for wet conditions.
Waterproofing and upper construction
Both shoes use GORE-TEX waterproof uppers, but the Lone Peak 9 GTX adds soft rolled mesh for comfort and durability, while the Timp 5 GTX ROA's GORE-TEX upper is tested and proven for durably waterproof, windproof, and breathable performance backed by the GORE-TEX GUARANTEED TO KEEP YOU DRY promise. That guarantee is a concrete confidence point for the Timp, but the Lone Peak's rolled mesh may feel softer against the foot on long days.
Grip and outsole
The Lone Peak 9 GTX uses a sticky MaxTrac outsole, which Altra describes as giving grip on any terrain. The Timp 5 GTX ROA is also described as grippy, but no outsole compound is named in the supplied facts. If you often run on wet roots and rocks, the Lone Peak's explicit MaxTrac specification is a clearer known quantity.
Cushioning and ground feel
The Lone Peak 9 GTX has an Altra EGO midsole that provides a slightly cushioned connection to the ground, so you keep some trail feedback. The Timp 5 GTX ROA is described as cushioned, which suggests a softer, more forgiving ride. Neither shoe's stack height is supplied, so use these descriptions as relative guidance rather than exact measurements.
Trade-offs to weigh
- Grip certainty vs. cushioning comfort: The Lone Peak 9 GTX names a sticky MaxTrac outsole, giving you a known grip reference for mixed terrain. The Timp 5 GTX ROA emphasizes cushioning and a guaranteed waterproof upper but does not name its outsole compound. If sure-footed traction on unpredictable wet ground is your top priority, lean Lone Peak; if a softer ride matters more, lean Timp. Match the trade-off to your most common trail surface.
- Ground feel vs. plush ride: The Lone Peak's Altra EGO midsole is described as a slightly cushioned connection to the ground, so you feel the trail. The Timp 5 GTX ROA is described as cushioned, which points to a more damped ride. Choose based on whether you prefer feedback or float. Consider how much ground feedback you want on long descents.
- Classic simplicity vs. collaborative style: The Lone Peak 9 GTX is a living legend with a classic Lone Peak feel and rolled mesh comfort. The Timp 5 GTX ROA is a collaboration with ROA that redefines functional fashion. Neither is objectively better; pick the one whose design you'll be happy to wear on repeat. Style is a valid tiebreaker when performance is close.
Product facts
- Men's Lone Peak 9 GTX: GORE-TEX Invisible Fit upper with soft rolled mesh; sticky MaxTrac outsole; Altra EGO midsole for a slightly cushioned connection to the ground. This combination suits runners who want waterproof protection without losing ground feel and need reliable grip on varied wet trails.
Men's Lone Peak 9 GTX - Women's Timp 5 GTX ROA: GORE-TEX upper tested and proven for durably waterproof, windproof, and breathable performance, backed by the GORE-TEX GUARANTEED TO KEEP YOU DRY promise; described as grippy and cushioned. This shoe is a strong choice for wet-weather trail running when you want a cushioned ride and verified waterproof confidence.
Women's Timp 5 GTX ROA
Who should choose which
Best for
- Runners who want a classic, slightly cushioned trail feel and sticky MaxTrac grip on mixed wet terrain
- Men seeking a waterproof trail shoe with soft rolled mesh comfort for long days
Not for
- Runners who prioritize maximum cushioning over ground feel
- Women who prefer a women's-specific fit and a fashion-forward trail aesthetic
